Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

Excommunicate drug traffickers: Bertone suggests

Published: January 14, 2009

Leaving on a visit to Mexico, Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone has suggested excommunication as a punishment for drug traffickers.

But the Church's severest form of rebuke would probably have little effect on the traffickers and killers who lack a religious conscience, Cardinal Bertone, conceded, the Los Angeles Times reports.

Speaking to Latin American journalists before traveling to Mexico, Cardinal Bertone said it was a "duty" to fight drug gangs because their actions represent "the most hypocritical and terrible way of murdering the dignity and personality of today's youth."

"Certainly, excommunication is a very harsh deterrent that the Church has used to deal with the most serious crimes in its history, from the very first centuries," Bertone said when asked if the censure would be appropriate. Excommunication bars a Catholic from receiving sacraments and participating in public worship.

"But I should observe that excommunication is a punishment that touches only those who have some form of ecclesiastical conscience, an ecclesiastical education," he added.

The Vatican, Cardinal Bertone said, is alarmed at the "disasters" of drug-fuelled violence, kidnappings and generalised insecurity in Mexico and, increasingly, in some of its Central American neighbours. He called on Catholics to pray for traffickers to have a change of heart.

Mexican President Felipe Calderon launched the country's army a little over two years ago in a nationwide offensive against powerful and well-armed drug gangs. Rather than pacify the country, the conflict has only increased the bloodshed. More than 5,000 people were killed last year alone.

Officially, the Church hierarchy in Mexico has been supportive of the government campaign while also urging dialogue and an end to violence. In some parts of the country, however, priests have been willing to accept money from local druglords to pay for church repairs or other community projects.

"They are very generous with the societies of their towns," Bishop Carlos Aguiar Retes, president of the Mexican Bishops Conference, said last April, according to the newspaper Reforma. In some remote towns, he said, "they put up lights, communications, roads, at their own expense ... often they also build a church or a chapel."

The remarks outraged many Mexicans, and Church officials later said the bishop was taken out of context.

"There are seminaries, churches, who accept money not knowing where it came from," Mercedes Murillo, president of the Sinaloan Civic Front in the city of Culiacan, a major drug-trafficking centre, said in a recent interview. "They wash their hands like Pontius Pilate."

SOURCE

Vatican suggests excommunicating Mexican drug traffickers (Los Angeles Times)

 

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location to the end of your email - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com

Recent Comments

  1. What about excommunicating those politicians who authorise mass murder, such as Robert Mugabe?

  2. 1. Is Robert Mugabe a Catholic anyway? If he is, he's definitely not going to be in God's good books.

    2. Why aren't the often vocal commenters commenting on this? Where are they? Is this issue not important enough?

    3. It's about time we did something like this.

  3. I never seem to be able to get my opinion printed in this online news source. I assume it is because, in spite of the fact that I am an orthodox, Roman Catholic, I criticise the prudential decisions and statements of the Church leadership.

    The idea to excommunicate drug traffickers in Mexico is ludicrous. Silly. Lacking in any understanding of the Mexican psyche or Mexican Catholicism.

    As an orthodox Catholic living in the midst of Mexicans I know the traffickers have their "saints" to protect their dealings and their Lady of Guadalupe pictures to bless them. It is in most cases a superstition, not a true devotion.

    What the Church needs to do is to educate the Mexicans in Mexico in their faith. It needs to form Mexicans with Christian consciences. It needs to form Mexico's politicians with a preference for its own poor. Mexico's politicians need to understand that sending out its young workers decimates its country, weakens its women and children and helps America's greedy corporations to exploit cheap labor at the expense of legal American residents.

    It also needs to support the erection of a fence between the United States and Mexico. It is that, and only that, along with high tech surveillance, that will reduce the violence and destruction of the drug and human traffickers.

    The Church needs to learn to listen to the people. Some of us, in fact many of us, are more educated in the facts and just as educated in the social justice principles of the Church as are the Hierarchy.

    If you dare to print this, I will gain great respect for your professional integrity.

    I am sure you understand my frustration. Please do not doubt my love for the Church or the Mexican people.

    Thank you.


  4. Collin

    Don't expect folks like Mr Haill etc to comment on topics like this - the thousands of folks who turn up dead yearly in Mexico related to drug crime simply don't register on their radar.

    Take aside the fact that the content of these crimes is actually far more horrendous than most else which is going on (eg. torture, beheadings, mass-murder etc) you'll never see them rant like they do when Israelis are involved. You've got to wonder why sometimes.

  5. Collin, yes, Mugabe is a Catholic. In the past he has made great show of his Catholicism, though he now seems to be closer to his "pet" Anglican archbishop. (Very strange considering his frequent vitriolic Anglophobia!) Not sure if he is still going to Mass and/or receiving Communion, but ISTM he is EXACTLY the sort of man for whom formal excommunication is suitable.

    Several Catholic dictators in the past have been excommunicated. Admittedly though, they were in predominantly-Catholic countries where the excommunication would have more political effect. And perhaps the Church thinks excommunication would only exacerbate Mugabe's xenophobia and increase his persecution of Catholic clergy.

    Ami, your first para is itself ludicrous. Surely you have noticed that the majority of our published comments criticise the prudential decisions and statements of the Church leadership? Often far more strongly than you have?

    I agree the Church should be doing all the other things you say (except for supporting the cruel and unfair "fence" - if the US and Mexico have a free trade agreement between them, why not a free flow of workers? Are motor cars and vegetables more important than people?), AS WELL as excommunicating drug dealers, which does not preclude any of the other measures.

  6. Excommunicating for drugs, fair enough, but what about the pedophile priests which the church seem to want to protect? Clean up your own back yard, Catholic Church.

Delicious

More from this section

  1. DNA may reveal origins of medieval monks' manuscripts

    A British scientist has discovered that it is possible to extract DNA samples from medieval parchment which may make it possible to identify the origins of ancient manuscripts including bibles and prayer books.

  2. Catholic couple refuse to abort siamese twins

    A British Catholic woman, who is pregnant with rare dicephalous twins, and her husband have refused to contemplate an abortion despite medical advice to do so.

  3. Like father, like son in the priesthood

    In possibly the first such event in Britain since Pope Gregory VII imposed mandatory priestly celibacy in the Latin Church, a British man, Dominic Cosslett, has been ordained a Catholic priest - like his father, Ron.

  4. Maltese lecturer "excommunicates" himself

    Maltese university lecturer, Dr Patrick Attard, who contested the last general election as the first openly gay candidate, has officially "excommunicated" himself from the Catholic Church.

  5. Vietnamese Catholics to appeal convictions

    Eight Vietnamese Catholics who were convicted recently over protests concerning the demolition and confiscation of Church property are appealing their cases to the Hanoi Appellate Court.

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Subscribe

Receive CathNews headlines in your inbox daily.

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.

Daily Prayer

Gospel Verse for 31 July 2010
...though [Herod] wanted to put [John] to death, he feared the people, because they held him to be a prophet. [Matthew 14:5]

View Podcast