Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

"Angels & Demons" harmless: Vatican paper

Published: May 08, 2009

L'Osservatore Romano reviewers have judged that Ron Howard's film Angels & Demons is commercial and inaccurate but ultimately "harmless'' entertainment.

The Vatican paper ran a review and an editorial in Wednesday's edition, critiquing the movie based on the Dan Brown bestselling novel of the same name, SF Gate reports.

The newspaper wrote the movie was "a gigantic and smart commercial operation" filled with "stereotyped characters." The paper suggested moviegoers could make a game out of finding the many historical inaccuracies in the plot.

However, L'Osservatore praised Howard's "dynamic direction" and the "magnificent" reconstruction of locations like St Peter's Basilica and the Sistine Chapel. Much of the film was shot on sets that painstakingly recreated church landmarks.

The film offers "more than two hours of harmless entertainment, which hardly affects the genius and mystery of Christianity," L'Osservatore's reviewer wrote. It's "a videogame that first of all sparks curiosity and is also, maybe, a bit of fun."

"The theme is always the same in both novels: a sect versus the Church, even though the parts of the good and the bad are distributed differently," L'Osservatore wrote Wednesday. "This time, with 'Angels & Demons,' the Church is on the side of the good guys."

The editorial said the novels presented the Church's positions in a "simplistic and partial" way. It said the success of Brown's works should push the Church to rethink the way it uses the media to present its message.

FULL STORY @

Vatican paper: 'Angels & Demons' film is harmless (SF Gate)

 

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location to the end of your email - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com

Recent Comments

  1. The Da Vinci Code was clearly a work of fiction.The book about Robert Hansson, an active and devout member of Opus Dei who was a traitor and caused many innocent deaths,was factual.The book was made into a film. I have read Angels And Demons and like Dan Brown`s former books,it did not weaken my faith

  2. Was it not possible to find the primary source of the article about Angels and Demons i.e. the actual review from the L'Osservatore Romano ? Newspapers are notorious for giving a slanted account of anything which is related to the Church.

  3. Noel, people object to Brown’s anti-Catholic works, not because they might weaken anybody’s faith, but because they are vicious lies (admittedly not quite as outrageous in A&D as in tDVC). Nobody likes having lies told about himself, his religion and its Founder. Catholics object for the same reason that Jews would rightly object to a book/film blatantly denying the Holocaust.

  4. The Da Vinci Code and Angels & Demons are fiction, and are written, marketed and sold as such. None of the events, characters or props are real, nor do the author or publisher present them as real. It's all illusion.

  5. Monk, each copy of the Da Vinci Code opens with a page headed "Facts". Each one of thse, which are repeated by the "expert" character in the novel, is a vicious calumny against Christ and/or the Catholic Church. The author has repeatedly insisted, in numerous media statements over several years, that these lies are facts. I personally know several people who have been convinced by Brown's books and films that these vicious lies are true. Yes, there are a lot of gullible people out there. That's why it's very wrong to invent, publish and promote lies impugning the integrity of any person or institution.

  6. An author pretending that his novel is fact is one of the oldest literary conceits.

  7. I would reserve my judgement until you have seen the movie or read the book. I hope The Vatican paper would not lead anyone into heresy; if so the CDF really needs to look into this publication as a matter of faith.

  8. Catholics are not stupid Ronk, stop patronising us by nannying us about everything, we can think for ourselves. Geee....

  9. The Da Vinci Code is not harmless. At the very least, it caters to the worst tendencies in modern thirst for "spirituality" and the modern taste for debunking. It perpetuates a popular gnostic error. I actually met someone at a party who claimed that it presented an interesting alternative!

    At the very least, the OR, if the report is correct, is being naive in its intellectualism. Movies like the Da Vinci Code and Angels and Demons, do in the real world destroy people's faith. Then, there is the point that The Da Vinci Code and Angels and Demons are simply trashy novels any way. Lastly, the Church is our mother and teacher, and the Pope our Father in God. It is a failure in the virtue of piety to see an insult offered to either as trivial, even if practically there is very little that can be done to stop the evil.

    On the other hand, I suspect though that this is not an isolated incident. OR has lately been quite naive in more ways than one. The latest edition has an editorial claiming that Obama is not that bad after all.

  10. Ronk, to equate the work of fiction writing to holocaust denial is a real long draw. You must think we Catholics are lacking intelligence.
    You’re hyperventilating your apocalyptic fear by pontificating over every issue, for God’s sake, if you believe in an almighty, have a bit more faith, I think God is way beyond being attacked don’t you?

  11. TJ, do you ever think before clicking “submit”? God is being attacked all the time, every day. How hilarious that you of all people accuse someone else of “hyperventilating” and “pontificating” and needing to “have a bit more faith”.
    I certainly don’t fear the Apocalypse – I am inspired and comforted by it.

    Holocaust-denial is actually if anything a very mild and insufficient analogy for Brown’s ultra-Christophobia. Brown not only denies that millions of Catholics have been persecuted and murdered for their faith, he claims as “fact” that the Catholic Church is one huge conspiracy to secretly amass wealth and hide the truth, which routinely murders anyone who threatens to reveal the truth.

  12. TJ Lawson,

    You may like to think that Catholics are not stupid, but sadly some really are. I remember when The Da Vinci Code was released hearing two middle aged Catholic women discussing the film. One of the women said of the movie, “apparently it’s all true”. No I wasn’t surprised just saddened not only by the silliness of the woman but also by those Catholics who refuse to challenge those enemies of the Church who deliberately spread lies about the Church to help breed hate and contempt for her.

    How can people be so silly to believe works of fiction? Do you ever watch Main Stream Media? They’re pretty good at presenting fiction as fact.

    In numerous interviews leading up to the release of The Da Vinci Code movie, Dan Brown repeatedly said the background information in the his book [The Da Vinci Code] was true – The following exchange between Matt Lauer and Dan Brown on NBC’s The Today Show is just one example:

    Matt Lauer: How much of this is based on reality in terms of things that actually occurred?"
    Dan Brown: Absolutely all of it.
    (Today Show, June 9, 2003)"

    Yet TJ you think the Church should just ignore the lies said about her. Why?

    PS. Last year I ventured into a large Main Stream bookstore. What was in the religious section? No not the Catechism of the Catholic Church but “Holy Blood Holy Grail”. The source of much of The Da Vinci Codes “historical facts”.

  13. I'm reading the comments and I am reminded of Goodwin's Law:

    "As an internet discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1."

  14. In fact according to surveys of those who have read “The Da Vinci Code” (e.g. Herald Sun 21/5/06) showed that about HALF of them now thought there was some truth in the central and most vicious of the scores of lies in the book/film: that Jesus and Mary Magdalen had a child, the Church hushed it up and a secret society once led by Leonardo has protected the “secret” until Brown revealed it. Brown’s books are novels but they are not purportedly set in some fantasy world; he claims their setting is the real world, he names real people and institutions and claims to be giving a real historical background.

    “Have a bit more faith”, TJ? Our Lord urged us to spread His truth to every man. Is it “faith” to simply stand by impassively whilst tens of millions are misled by blatant lies in direct opposition to Christ’s Truth, and shrug it off with “people should be smart enough to work out the Truth for themselves; if they aren’t, too bad for them.”? Or is it faithlessness in Christ and His commandments?

  15. What a good thing, then, Ronk, that the misled tens of millions have you to explain things to them. Go get yourself a blog and enlighten them. You could begin by explaining to them the difference between lies and fiction.

Delicious

More from this section

  1. Chaser flies balloon over Vatican

    Australian TV comedy team The Chaser is in hot water again after allegedly flying a blimp into protected airspace above the Vatican.

  2. Swiss Guard to look at women

    Women may be allowed to join the Vatican's exclusive Swiss Guard, Commander Daniel Anrig has told Italian TV.

  3. Peres pressures Israel govt to cede sites

    Israel President Shimon Peres is pressing his government to cede sovereignty over key Christian holy sites to the Vatican, reports say.

  4. Uren awarded ACU's highest honour

    Australian Catholic University has awarded its highest honour to Melbourne's Newman College Rector, Fr Bill Uren in recognition of his work in the area of bioethics.

  5. FBT crackdown an attack on charity workers: Quinlan

    Catholic Social Services chief Frank Quinlan has described a mooted crackdown on fringe benefits for the not-for-profit sector as "a fundamental attack on wages and conditions of employees who are already often being paid below market rates."

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Subscribe

Receive CathNews headlines in your inbox daily.

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.

Daily Prayer

Gospel Verse for 31 July 2010
...though [Herod] wanted to put [John] to death, he feared the people, because they held him to be a prophet. [Matthew 14:5]

View Podcast