Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

Papal move on Anglicans provokes debate

Published: October 23, 2009

Archbishop Philip Freier

---

The Anglican Archbishop of Melbourne Philip Freier says it would be regrettable if some of the church's clergy joined the Catholic Church, while Traditional Anglican Communion leader Archbishop John Hepworth, says he expects many Australian Anglo-Catholics to leave.

ABC reports Archbishop Freier saying he estimates up to 30 Melbourne clergy consider themselves to be Anglo-Catholics, and "if people have a decision on conscience, I'd want to respect that because I think that we're fortunate to live in a society where our religious beliefs are a matter of principle and conscience."

Archbishop Hepworth said disagreement over female priesthood is one reason Anglicans are split.

"We simply say that priesthood is reserved for males and we say that in conjunction with the world's Catholic Church and the Churches of the East," he said.

The Australian Catholic Bishops Conference Chair of the Bishops Commission for Ecumenism and Interreligious Relations, Bishop Michael Putney, said in a separate statement on Wednesday that the Vatican announcement followed petitions received over a four or five year period from different Anglican groups.

"There has always been a practice of receiving into full communion individual Anglicans through the centuries, but this new provision will make it possible for groups or communities to enter full communion and remain together," said Bishop Putney.

The Age newspaper cited Anglo-Catholic bishops of the mainstream Anglican Church, Ross Davies of the Murray and Michael Hough of Ballarat, saying that many Australian Anglicans would find the Pope's offer attractive.

Bishop Davies reportedly called it the most significant decision about the two churches since the 16th century Reformation.

"It's really radical," he said. "I'm shocked and pleased. It will allow Anglo-Catholics a way to leave with dignity, and the Anglican Church can get on with its real fight between evangelicals and liberals."

He, however, doesn't expect "a great stampede". The report said that Bishop Hough, who was a Catholic priest before becoming Anglican, would remain Anglican.

Other Melbourne Anglo-Catholic priests said they would have to see the details before deciding what they would do.

Kooyong priest Christopher Seton said he and many others would be strongly tempted.

"Evangelical and liberal Anglicans treat us as a dotty old aunt, locked up in the attic and forgotten while they wait for us to die," he said in The Age.

"This is a moment of grace, a chance to put things right for holy Christians who have had their faith broken and lives wrecked by the betrayal of the faith in this country."

FULL STORY AND STATEMENT

'Regrettable' if Anglican clergy leave for Catholic church (ABC)

Anglicans to be welcomed into Catholic Church (Australian Catholic Bishops Conference)

Anglo-Catholics rejoice as Pope offers return to fold (The Age)

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com


 


Recent Comments

  1. Welcome home, guys. Glad to have you back on board. God Bless you all.

  2. In other words, Invictus Maneo is saying: if you differ from us, you're bound for condemnation, watch out for the other edge of the knife.

  3. Statements of regret or surprise sit uneasily with the reality of Anglican affairs in Australia. Not so much as a civil war but a way of life.The moratorium having failed there is nowhere to go for some than out.The body of the Church so divided needs healing and this is an opportunity for the continuing Anglican of whatever belief to take stock and go back to their theological roots to discern why they can be so disparate in their beliefs.Practically a fair path will have to be made to divide property especially if a whole parish leaves the Anglican Communion.The Catholic Church will have to become more aware of what property is usable for joining members if so requested.This is harder than it seems as 'church' property is held by a wide variety of religious organisations and no one in bigger diocese seems to have an overview.Providentially 'all will be well' as the great Englishwoman Julian of Norwich taught us.

  4. Pope Benedict XVI just keeps on getting better and wiser. He certainly is the Pope for the times. God Bless him and welcome to our former separated Brethren

  5. Amen Invictus ... Welcome Home to all. Its a joyous occasion.
    Some Oxymoron sounds biased and in a rut. It's not a question of being different from us, its a question of acknowledging the damage from the past and fixing it the way Christ wanted, with love and unity.
    Property issues ... cannot see anything major there.

  6. What does this move make for serious, fair dinkum ecumenism (the prayer of Jesus 'that they may all be one'), of Catholic priests trying to remain faithful to the rule of celibacy, and of women that God is calling to leadership or priesthood? It falls short of God-given common sense.

  7. Just make sure there are no Masons amongst them.

  8. We thank God for our true Aglican brothers and sisters in Faith, we are all on the same journery.
    Any move for us all to be under the "One Banner of Christ". 'That they all may we be one, under One Sheperd' is the moving of the Holy Spirit.

  9. Charles, God doesn't call women to the priesthood. Women cannot be ordained any more than can a cat or a ham sandwich can be; it is ontologically impossible, and no Pope can change that.

  10. A great source of future priests and bishops! They will be very compliant as they have probably left the Anglicans because they do not believe in ordaining women.

  11. I am absolutely dumbfounded by the decision. This decision seems to be aimed at solving a problem created by human need rather than in openness and discernment to the Spirit of God. We are continuing to live in the past without looking at the changing social and cultural reality of our world and to reinterpret practice so that it is relevant for today and will lead to a more vibrant and inclusive church in the future. Where do faith and the teachings of Jesus come into this move? To name this move as an answer to Jesus' prayer, 'that all may be one', is a farce, for within in the churches, both Catholic and Anglican divisions remain and will probably multiply in response to this move. We have enough divise hierachical structure without adding to the already complex structure in the church, structures that will undoubtedly lead to greater exclusion rather than inclusion of all.
    I pray for the Anglicans to sort out their own issues rather than look to escape them. Will this really serve true ecumenism?
    Posted by 'Where are we really heading?'

  12. Faith is NOT about changing with the Times it is about TRUTH and what is True. This IS the work of the HOLY SPIRIT, BERNIE, because the Holy Spirit seeks unity and peace not division. Will this cause further division amongst Anglicans and Catholics? No, not among Catholics who are faithful to the teachings of Christ and love the Holy Father. Catholics should rejoice and pray that further unity will eventuate not complain and foster negative will.
    This is a historical event in which Traditional Anglicans have themselves made requests to the Holy Father. This is a clear sign that this is God's will since Traditional Anglicans desire it. Will this serve true ecumenism? YES, because it is based on the true and full teachings of Jesus Christ and His Church. Truth leads to unity because the Holy Spirit can only act where there is TRUTH.
    Thanks be to God. May it be blessed and strengthened and only Good come out of it.

  13. It would be helpful if, for an intelligent discussion regarding Anglicans who may wish to join the Catholic Church, those who wish to join would comment. Instead firstly read: "Note of the Congregation of the Faith about personlal ordinariates for Anglicans entering the Catholic Church".

Bookmark and Share

More from this section

  1. Pope opens path for Anglicans to enter the Church

    Pope Benedict is publishing an Apostolic Constitution introducing a structure to allow the establishment of "personal ordinariates" for Anglicans who wish to enter full communion with the Catholic Church.

  2. Row over Holy Communion presider

    Sydney Anglican Archbishop, Peter Jensen is facing a legal challenge over his church's decision to break with the national church and permit deacons or church workers to preside over Holy Communion.

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Mass streamed live daily

From Our Lady of the Rosary Cathedral, Waitara, in the Broken Bay Diocese.
Weekdays live at 9.30am
Saturdays live 9.30am (followed by Adoration and Benediction)
Sundays live 9.30am
Click on this link at the appropriate time to connect.

Subscribe

To receive headlines from our faith-based news services, please subscribe below.

Email address

Newsletter


 

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.
Subscribe to Faith Project RSS.