Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

Catholic ethicist backs androgyny recognition

Published: March 12, 2010

A leading Catholic ethicist has endorsed the decision to recognise a 48-year-old Sydney woman as the first person in NSW to officially be neither man nor woman.

The woman known as Norrie, has become the first person in NSW to be officially recognised as neither man nor woman by the state, receiving a certificate from the Registry of Births, Deaths and Marriages that says "sex not specified".

A spokeswoman for the Attorney-General's department confirmed it was the first such certificate to state non-specified gender, and that even intersex children have their sex determined within weeks of birth, reports the Sydney Morning Herald.

Norrie, who identifies as neuter and uses only a first name, was born in Scotland (and used the surname May-Welby), so the document was not a birth certificate but a Recognised Details Certificate - the version given to immigrants who have changed sex and want it recorded.

The law had not considered that anyone might want neither sex recorded but was able to accommodate the request when presented with evidence from two registered doctors that Norrie was physically and psychologically androgynous, it adds.

Norrie was registered as male at birth, began hormone treatment at 23 and had surgery to become a woman - but has since ceased taking hormones, preferring to live as neither male nor female.

Catholic ethicist, Nicholas Tonti-Filippini from the John Paul II Institute, said birth certificates should also record no gender in such cases, updated with ''any changes to phenotypic gender''.

He said there was a trend against the practice of selecting a sex for intersex children, which could mean more androgynous people in future.

FULL STORY

Sexless in the city: a gender revolution (Sydney Morning Herald)

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location to the end of your email - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com

Recent Comments

  1. I wonder whether the Church will tell this person that it cannot form a intimate relationship with another person too?

  2. John M: As long as that relationship is within marriage and open to life (conceiving children).

  3. Congratulations on having the strength to be who you were created to be, Norrie. May peace and safety enfold you.

  4. Jesus said in the kindom of heaven there is no master and slave, no gentile and jew, no male or female. Praise God!

  5. This is wonderful news. Norrie is neither man nor woman and should be treated and recognised as such.
    As a catholic I am appalled at the Catholic churches treatment of people who are intersexed, transgended and non-gendered.
    I am also appalled that this article refers to Norrie as woman when even zies legal documentation recognises zie is non-gended

  6. Anthony: You support marriage regardless of the genders of the participants? Are you saying that people who are infertile shouldn't be allowed to get married?

  7. It is a well known fact amongst relevant scientists that the XXY gene exists, and that for those in such a position, life can be very difficult, particularly made so by ill-informed members of society.
    A good example is the athlete from Africa. While information concerning her case has remained scant, I was aware that the XXY gene could be one explanation. The life of the athlete was made extremely dificult until her government stepped in, and rightly so.
    Like everthing in human nature, ignorance breeds fear and fear results in persecution and/or death.
    I am pleased that there has been a favourable outcome for Norrie.

  8. Years ago, medical students at Tulane were told of a recent case of a truly androgynous (not neither man nor woman) both male and female person. Coming with a complaint of kidney disease, with blood in the urine repeatedly, he agreed to exploratory surgery when lab tests continued to show normal kidney function.
    A medical student suggested Menstruation, when history revealed episodes of bleeding about a month apart. Surgery found a complete set of female organs, with a short vagina emptying into the bladder. Surgeons could decide which set of organs to remove - and decided that since the farmer-patient was married, had two children, had always lived as a male, they would remove the ovaries, tubes, and uterus, and simply tell him 'We found the trouble and fixed it.'
    They had his permission for the Exploratory but not for the Removal of any organ. They had an ethical dilemma. A year later the patient was in good health and happy.

Delicious

More from this section

  1. Church needs to clean up, says Papal adviser

    An adviser to Pope Benedict, Cardinal Walter Kasper, has told an Italian newspaper that the Church needs to clean up its act over child abuse, by compensating victims and punishing the perpetrators.

  2. Protest Nigerian massacre, govt urged

    The Australian Christian Lobby wants the Federal Government to voice concern over the massacre of hundreds of Christians near the Nigerian city of Jos and more actively assist persecuted people groups overseas.

  3. Priestly celibacy is important: Vatican

    The Vatican has reaffirmed the importance of celibacy for the clergy, after Austria's Archbishop Christoph Schoenborn suggested a link between celibacy and abuse.

     

  4. iPhone rosary and other devotional apps for Catholics

    The iPhone's 140 million-plus applications now include one that helps Catholics pray the rosary.

  5. 100 Anglican parishes in vote to go Catholic

    About 100 traditionalist parishes of the Anglican Church in America (ACA) across the United States will convert en-masse to the Catholicism.

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Subscribe

Receive CathNews headlines in your inbox daily.

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.

Daily Prayer

Gospel Verse for 31 July 2010
...though [Herod] wanted to put [John] to death, he feared the people, because they held him to be a prophet. [Matthew 14:5]

View Podcast