Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

The Vatican's very own revolution

Published: October 05, 2012

On January 25, 1959, the newly elected Pope John XXIII invited 18 cardinals from the Vatican bureaucracy to attend a service at the Basilica of St Paul Outside the Walls in Rome. He told them he planned to summon a global church council. The horrified cardinals were speechless, which the Pope mischievously chose to interpret as devout assent, writes Barney Zwartz in The Age.

But, in reality, the Vatican bureaucrats, known as the Curia, were aghast. The Pope, 77, had been elected purely as a caretaker, but here he was indulging a novel, unpredictable, dangerous and, above all, they believed, unnecessary notion.

In their view it would create ungovernable expectations and might even lead to changes. And if there were to be changes - always undesirable - then the Curia would manage them without any outside intervention, as they had for centuries.

They regrouped and fought back. If they could not avoid the council, then they would control it. They proposed 10 commissions controlled by Curia members to run the council, which would discuss 70 documents prepared by the Curia. Everything was designed to reinforce the status quo.

But the world's bishops, led by a generation of outstanding European theologians, were in no mood to submit. They simply sidestepped the careful preparation and arranged their own agendas.

The Curia were right to worry. What Pope John unleashed, now known as Vatican II, was the most momentous religious event since Martin Luther launched the Protestant Reformation 450 years earlier.

''It was a revolution,'' says American theologian John Markey. ''It was the most fundamental shift in self-understanding by the church in 1500 years. It is not over yet.''

The winds of change proved more like a tornado, leaving almost nothing untouched. It is difficult for people under 60 to grasp how radical, how wide-ranging and how deep the effects were because they do not remember the church as it was before the council - ''frozen in a time warp'', as Jesuit priest Gerald O'Collins told The Age.

Pope John intended the church to emerge from behind the battlements, lower the drawbridge and engage with the modern world. The most obvious and visible change for Catholics in the pew was worship in their own language rather than in Latin, with the priest now facing them rather than the altar, plus an affirmation of the role of laypeople.

But there were other profound developments such as a willingness to engage with other churches, even other faiths, a renewed focus on social justice, and a decentralised approach to authority in the church.

Today, as religious culture wars between traditionalists and progressives rack the church in the West, Vatican II has become the key battlefield. Both sides want to define and control the council's legacy.

FULL STORY The Vatican's very own revolution (Age)

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com


 


Recent Comments

  1. Now the Church is being driven, forwards, but the drivers are not looking forward only looking in the rear-view mirror.

  2. 'Location, location, location' boomed the Professor of Economics in my first class at University.
    Value in the real estate market comes from the perceived advatages of a property's location.
    So it is with the Church. Depending on where you are situated, the perceptions can be quite different.
    Cardinal Pell reassures us that the 'battle is over.'
    The author of the above article reminds us that the battle still rages 'for the control of the Council's legacy.'
    And in a related contribution, Ladislas Orsy offers the view that 'the Spirit is still breaking through', still causing growth and development.
    The older and more conservative members of the hierarchy would have us believe that all is well back at the ranch.
    The progressives would have us believe that what John XXIII began, has a long course yet to run. The former have nailed their flag to the wall of the fight against secularism. The latter,fly the flag for continuing 'aggiornamento'.
    Our world and age are characterised by discontinuous change, the kind of change for which we were not prepared (the internet; landings on the moon; Hiroshima.....).
    Such change has also embraced the Church. Love it or hate it, discontinuous change, sourced in many locations, is here to stay --- and that helps to define how we should be Church.

  3. Let's hear a word of praise for Barney Zwartz. For a secular journalist I found the article balanced but I found the headline, The Vatican's very own revolution, did not encapsulate the real revolution.
    Vatican 2 undermined the absolutist hierarchy by promoting the concept of The People of God. See Lumen Gentium.
    However since then the concept and the living out of what the concept entails has been swamped by those who are happier with the old concept of the Church Militant.
    The language of the Church Militants is the language of war, battle against, fighting with various social-philosophical-theological theories and their followers.
    The language of catholics who see themselves as blessed to be able to recognise others as fellow members of The People of God. Their language is the language of peace, cooperation, dialogue. The things that unite us are more important than the things that divide us.
    Of course the above is an extreme simplification of division within the church. But so too is the progressive v conservative dichotomy.
    The revolution is not over. The struggle for the hearts and minds of catholics continues.
    Let's hope Benedict's Year of Faith promotes dialogue not confrontation.

  4. I won't be taking my cues from Barry Zwartz on the history or direction of the Council, the Church or anything else for that matter.
    The Second Vatican Council was important for the Church. But the Church didn't start in 1962. The sooner we stop pretending it did the better off we will be.

Bookmark and Share

More from this section

  1. Doctor's ministry bridges science and spirit

    Forty years ago, long before the recent afternoon when Dr Joseph Dutkowsky knelt at the warped feet of his four-year-old patient, he was an American small-town teenager approaching his Catholic confirmation and needing to select a patron saint. He made an unlikely choice, a newly canonised figure, St Martin de Porres, the illegitimate child of a former black slave in 16th-century Peru. Decades later, providence has bent the vectors of faith and science together in the career of Dr Dutkowsky, reports The New York Times.

  2. Is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife?

    Mark 10:2-16

    Some Pharisees came, and to test Jesus they asked, ‘Is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife?’ 3He answered them, ‘What did Moses command you?’ 4They said, ‘Moses allowed a man to write a certificate of dismissal and to divorce her.’ 5But Jesus said to them, ‘Because of your hardness of heart he wrote this commandment for you. 6

  3. How Vatican II raised my expectations of being a Catholic

    Why am I still a Catholic? In truth, sometimes I'm not sure why. Yet I know the Church frames my identity. I suspect Vatican II's central idea of a Pilgrim Church definitely influenced my thinking as a young 20-something believer. It raised my expectations. It stretched my idea of faith, writes Geraldine Doogue in a reflection published in Eureka Street.

  4. Ignite festival, exorcism book, MacKillop internet forum

    The Ignite Youth festival sets Brisbane on fire, Sydney Auxiliary Bishop Julian Porteous (pictured) releases a book on exorcism, an internet forum on St Mary MacKillop brings strangers together, and a church in Sydney's Rocks promotes the the cause of its Marist founder.

     

  5. Albanian feud, Mary McAleese, Brazilian soccer photo

    Albanian Catholics excommunicate participants in a blood feud, the former president of Ireland, Mary McAleese, writes a book on the impact of Vatican II, the Pope has a new almoner and Brazilian bishops have slammed a magazine over publishing a photo of a crucified soccer star.

     

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Mass streamed live daily

From Our Lady of the Rosary Cathedral, Waitara, in the Broken Bay Diocese.
Weekdays live at 9.30am
Saturdays live 9.30am (followed by Adoration and Benediction)
Sundays live 9.30am
Click on this link at the appropriate time to connect.

Subscribe

To receive headlines from our faith-based news services, please subscribe below.

Email address

Newsletter


 

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.
Subscribe to Faith Project RSS.