Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

Uni head calls on Cardinal to address college behaviour

Published: November 05, 2012

The University of Sydney vice-chancellor, Michael Spence, yesterday called on the Catholic Archbishop of Sydney, Cardinal Pell, who is the figurehead of St John's College, to ''do all he can to sort out" the culture of loutish behaviour by its resident students, reports The Sydney Morning Herald.

''The college does not report to me or to the university, and the university is not represented on the college council,'' Dr Spence said.

''The governance of the college rests with the college council, which includes six representatives of the Catholic Church. I would urge Archbishop Pell to do all he can to sort out this issue.''

Cardinal Pell yesterday issued a statement supporting action. “If the reports today are accurate, decisive action is required. Enough is enough. Turmoil and bitter division have continued at the College for months, even after two independent reviews. Any allegation of criminal conduct must be referred to the police," his statemernt said.

In March, 33 students were suspended for allegedly being involved in the now infamous ''O'' Week ritual that left a teenage girl close to death in hospital.

Seven of the 33 have now seized all but two positions on next year's college council, including the top three of president, secretary and treasurer.

In the weeks after the female student was injured by an initiation ritual, Mr Bongers, University of Sydney officials and Cardinal Pell's office collectively agreed to draft in an impartial adjudicator.Ken Handley was a recently retired, highly respected judge from the NSW Court of Appeal.

After considering the evidence - and failing to flush out the ringleaders - he ordered the group to complete between five and 20 hours' community service.

The shadow federal treasurer, Joe Hockey, a former student resident at St John's, said yesterday the reported behaviour was unacceptable and deserving of investigation.''If there is inappropriate treatment of any person, then it deserves proper investigation and, where appropriate, it deserves to be properly punished,'' Mr Hockey said.

But wild behaviour was prevalent on campuses around the world, he said. He confirmed initiation rituals occurred at St John's when he was a student.''Let's not gild the lily on this sort of stuff,'' he said.

''I think if you open the lid on colleges and campuses and frat houses right around the world … by the general standard of behaviour, it would be deemed to be pretty lewd and inappropriate.''

FULL STORY Meet the pride of St John's - The Untouchables (SMH)

Insider speaks out over brutish college initiations (Yahoo7)

RELATED COVERAGE

Cardinal steps in

RELEASE

Cardinal Pell on St John's College allegations

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com


 


Recent Comments

  1. I think that this behaviour is the product of male students who have come from elitist private schools.
    There is absolutely no excuse what so ever for this extreme behaviour.
    I spent my apprenticeship in the Merchant Navy in an all male environment, and while I admit to doing a few dumb and stupid things, the behaviour of we apprentices was always respectful, because our attitudes was honed by the hard work we did and environment on ships that we worked in.

  2. There is no excuse for this abusive and bullying behaviour.
    It makes me embarrassed when these louts are representing one of our 'best' Catholic university colleges.
    These young men are obviously spoilt and I have to wonder how much influence they and possibly their parents have, when they have never faced criminal charges. And they say they are Christians!
    I would not send a youth there under any circumstances. A strong and unforgiving policy is needed with supervisors who are strong enough to expel those who are guilty.
    I applaud Cardinal Pell's comments and only hope that he can follow through with the discipline that is needed.

  3. I’m not sure what you really mean -- in your synopsis of this story -- by calling the Cardinal Archbishop the “figurehead” of St John’s College at Sydney University.
    He is, legally, the “Visitor” to the university – a term and role which were left in the revision of the original act [of the 1850s] when it was passed by the NSW Parliament in the 1990s.
    The term, “Visitor” is not really defined in the Act, but nor are its scope and powers limited in any way. A “Visitor” can resolve disputes in such an organisation and issue instructions: potentially [it seems akin to the “Reserve” powers of a state Governor or the Governor-General, which, as we know, remain real, notwithstanding that they’re been seldom exercised].
    So the Cardinal’s powers in this case are actually substantial – he is, potentially, far more than a mere “figurehead”.

  4. What is it about Catholic men's culture that leads to this... how many of the ringleaders have been through the same at all boys Catholic schools?
    Is the inability to deal with this connected to the difficulty of dealing with sexual abuse?
    What does it say about power and control?

  5. The purpose of the college system is to house a community of scholars bound by disciplinary knowledge or religious belief.
    The Oxbridge system actually attaches more importance to the college system than to the disciplinary base of members, establishing articles of association and a kind of clubbishness that sometimes passes for preserving an atmosphere that sustains the studious-minded.
    Meanwhile the law as well as university statutes have overridden the codes of behaviour that colleges were once expected to follow, while serious breaches of behaviour by staff and students on campus are indeed the responsibility of university administrators to address.
    I was once warden of a university college which professed all of the above values, while caving into the economic reality of leasing out rooms to all comers.
    The clash between the two realities meant that college values were constantly under threat, particularly by some students who chose to do as they pleased.
    While the Catholic Chaplain of the university in question was appointed as Visitor, the reality was that his influence was ignored.
    I soon learnt that real power was exercised, not by myself, but by Senior Tutors and Residential Assistants.
    While some of them were exemplary leaders, the majority held sway by virtue of a system of election that guaranteed them their positions in return for turning a blind eye to unacceptable and sometimes disgraceful behaviour.
    I resigned rather than having to rubberstamp this.
    The Cardinal should disband the Board and invite the VC to place the college under university administration.

  6. The college bullies are generally the products of the Catholic education system.
    The good student folk in college who by their inaction allow evil to flourish are also generally the products of the Catholic education system.
    What is the collective blindness or psychopathology that allows this evil?
    Where are the idealistic, clearheaded, sensitive, justice aware, courageous students standing up to and challenging the rotten system?
    Where are these courageous, idealistic young women and men?
    We have no evidence they are resident in St John's.

Bookmark and Share

More from this section

  1. Benedict XVI forced to cancel peace mission to Syria

    Instability and increasing violence in Syria have prompted Pope Benedict XVI to cancel the planned visit to the war-torn nation by a delegation of cardinals and bishops, the Catholic Herald reports.

  2. Theologian's cancelled invitation linked to Vatican-supported group

    The University of San Diego cancelled a British theologian's fellowship after an influential alumnus and a conservative watchdog group backed by a high-ranking Vatican official protested the appointment to the university's board of trustees, reports NCR Online.

  3. Catholic university lawyers take journalist to court

    Lawyers for the principal of a Catholic university college are to apply for a court order in an attempt to force the editor of the website Independent Catholic News to reveal the identity of an anonymous source, reports The Tablet.

  4. Catholic-raised artist wins religious art prize

    Catholic-raised Sydney artist, Fabian Astore, has been named a joint winner of the 2012 Blake Prize for Religious Art for his video of a ittle girl runing carefree in concentric circles past 20 men worshipping in Istanbul's Suleymaniye Mosque, reports The Sydney Morning Herald.

  5. Pope sends message of congratulations to Obama

    Pope Benedict XVI has congratulated US President Barack Obama on his re-election, saying that he prayed the ideals of freedom and justice that guided America's founders might continue to flourish, reportds the Catholic News Service.

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Mass streamed live daily

From Our Lady of the Rosary Cathedral, Waitara, in the Broken Bay Diocese.
Weekdays live at 9.30am
Saturdays live 9.30am (followed by Adoration and Benediction)
Sundays live 9.30am
Click on this link at the appropriate time to connect.

Subscribe

To receive headlines from our faith-based news services, please subscribe below.

Email address

Newsletter


 

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.
Subscribe to Faith Project RSS.