Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

Blogwatcher - Resurrecting Richard III or burying Gaudium et Spes

Published: February 10, 2013

BY STEFAN GIGACZ

Five hundred years after his death, Shakespeare's tragic anti-hero Richard III ("my kingdom for a horse") is back in the news with the discovery of his skeleton.

But as Mark Shea notes, "it's tough to be the victim of the greatest butt-kissing hatchet job in history done by the greatest poet in the English language".

And while many academics argue that Shakespeare was himself a Catholic, Cristina Odone at the UK Telegraph is demanding that the king's bones should also be given a church burial:

Richard III may have been a murderer, or he may have been a much-maligned monarch. He was certainly one of the most controversial kings in English history, the last Plantagenet, and afflicted by scoliosis. He was also a Catholic. Now that his remains have been disinterred, he should be buried in a Catholic church with Catholic funeral rites.

Anything else would shock him. He wouldn't recognise the unfamiliar rites of an Anglican state ceremony. He'd regard the established Church as sacrilegious, the work of a hateful Tudor who'd taken the divine right of kings too far.

Fr James Martin SJ adds that he has found the whole saga fascinating:

For it serves as a gentle reminder that "legendary" location often prove to be "factual." When I was in the Holy Land I was reminded several times by guidebooks that "legendary" or "traditional" places for an event are often later found to be based in fact, for several reasons.

First, people in antiquity (and in the middle ages) didn't move around as much, and so when pilgrims would return later on, it was easy for locals to point out where something happened. If they didn't know, their parents, who did know, would have told them. In other words, those returning to Galilee in the decades after Jesus's death would have been told by locals, "Yes, that miracle was done right over there."

Second, these were extraordinary events, and thus more likely to be recalled. Finally, we underestimate the accuracy of oral traditions. So for many years Richard's body was "thought" to have been located near a church near Bosworth Field, and here it is.

For many years St Peter's tomb was "reputed" to be under St. Peter's dome, and there it was. The next time someone points out a "legendary" site of a special event, don't dismiss it: pay attention.

 

On another level, after American ex-atheist and Catholic convert Jennifer Fulwiler gave a talk recently, two women approached her to tell their story:

They explained that they are both cradle Catholics who have gone to Mass pretty much every Sunday for their whole lives. They love their faith and are proud to be Catholic. And they both use artificial contraception. They explained that they had not fully understood that the Church was serious about this teaching...

Neither Amanda nor Laura had heard anything about the topic in their many years of Catholic school and religious formation classes. And so for all of their married lives they'd used various forms of contraception, never questioning how it might jibe with the doctrines of their faith.

But, Fulwiler continues, more and more Catholic women are awakening to what the Church teaches:

I see women who are beginning to see that artificial methods of birth control come with their own problems, and whose gut instincts tell them that there just might be some truth to this idea that contraception has not been a good thing for us. In short, I see a generation of Catholic women who are poised to reject the lies of secular culture and embrace the fullness of their Church's teaching, but who will need a lot of help to get there.

Reading this inspired me to look up John Billings who with his wife Evelyn developed the Billings method of natural family planning. And it turns out that this year marks the 60th anniversary of Billings' 1953 discovery of the physiological basis of their method.

So I googled "60th anniversary Billings ovulation method". Nothing that I can find! No man is a prophet, etc. I guess that also helps explain why Amanda and Laura never heard anything about the method. Seems that it's not just Catholic Social Teaching that is the "Church's best kept secret".

Speaking of anniversaries, I was also going to mention that this month marks the 50th anniversary of the beginning of work on the drafting of the document that would become the Vatican II Constitution on the Church in the World of Our Time, Gaudium et Spes (GS).

But it's a document that doesn't seem to impress Professor Tracey Rowland who analysed it this week in a post ominously entitled "The good, the bad and Gaudium et Spes"!

Professor Rowland writes:

It is easy to be critical of Gaudium et Spes as a document pushed through at the end of the Second Vatican Council when the Holy Spirit was out to lunch or the Conciliar fathers had eaten rather too much lunch and were not fully awake. As one of my students once remarked, “Were they all on Prozac?”

Actually, no, Professor Rowland hastens to answer, before launching into her critique:

At its worst, Gaudium et Spes became an excuse for correlating, and even accommodating, the faith to the culture of modernity. It became, in other words, the license for what we now call the “spirit of the Council” — the practice of identifying fashionable trends in the secular culture and tying the faith to them in a pathetic marketing ploy.

This is what Ratzinger called the practice of presenting the Church as a poorly managed haberdashery shop constantly changing its windows to lure more customers.

I'm feeling a little bit stunned, or perhaps depressed, at this point but fortunately she does go on to say that:

At its best, on the other hand, Gaudium et Spes served as a foundation for the theological anthropology advanced in John Paul II’s Trinitarian encyclicals—Redemptor Hominis, Dives in Misericordia, and Dominum et Vivificantem—and his more famous catechesis on human love.

All that could raise quite a discussion. Still, it's worth mentioning that Msgr Pierre Haubtmann, the editor of the final drafts of GS, was no intellectual slouch, holding three doctorates in sacred theology, scholastic philosophy and sociology.

And he and his team, many of whom also worked on Lumen Gentium (LG), certainly did not compile the document over coffee and croissants as is evident from even a quick glance at Haubtmann's conciliar archive, the mere inventory of which totals nearly 200 pages! Moreover, it took around 34 months to complete GS compared to around 22 months for LG.

While on the subject of Catholic Social Teaching, environmental engineer Geoff Lacey is calling for Sustainable Economics in a new post at the Social Policy Connections website:

In recent years, I have taken part in a lot of discussions about sustainability. I have found that many people agree we must work towards a profound transformation in our culture and in its patterns of production and consumption if we are to find a way out of the present environmental crisis. People then raise one particular urgent question: can there be a different kind of economy that will be sustainable, and will it work?

Still in the ecological arena, WWF worker Dekila Chungyalpa talks about a new Sacred Earth program to get religious leaders involved in conservation issues in this interview at New Scientist.

 

Over at SocialSpirituality.net, Sandie Cornish asks whether we knew that St Josephine Bakhita was a victim of trafficking.

 

Meanwhile, in the UK, following the British parliament's vote on same sex marriage, Fr Alexander Lucie-Smith reflects on the challenges of defending Catholic teaching against accusations of bigotry:

Are you a bigot? It seems I am in the eyes of some tweeters who accuse me of ‘disgusting bigotry’. The word bores me, so I automatically block anyone who uses it, and cannot thus find the tweets in question. That does not matter.

The person who uses the word ‘bigot’ does not say anything interesting; he or she merely hurls an insult, and as far as I can see the only reason anyone has ever called me a bigot is because I am a Catholic. For them Catholicism equals bigotry; but that is not really a very profound point. It is merely a way of saying that they do not like Catholics, and an attempt to hurt our feelings.

People need to be careful about stirring up religious and sectarian hatreds. Hence, let us do away with the word ‘bigot’. It was disappointing to see the word feature in an article by Polly Toynbee recently and in the headline to the article.

“The gay marriage debate has uncovered a nest of bigots,” screams the headline. Those who voted against gay marriage were not bigots; they were people Polly Toynbee does not agree with, as is her perfect right. But to use this insulting word in this way is generates only heat, never light.

For something completely different, the Faithworks blog at the US Catholic Relief Service links to interviews with the Catholic Harbaugh brothers, John and Jim, whose teams fought out last week's Superbowl XLVII.

Finally, with Ash Wednesday coming up this week, Damien Brennan reflects on the challenges of trying to live simply in the wake of a family visit to Cambodia:

We were close to the daily lives of people living in villages and along the roadsides as we traversed Cambodia by challenging road travel. We were often in the throng of children heading to or from school, sometimes three small children precariously sharing an oversized pushbike on narrow, crowded and treacherous roads.

We stopped regularly to look at the food growing in the fields or at the plethora of roadside markets. We talked with people when we could. We observed simple one or two room dwellings built on poles with eating and family space underneath. Small earthen ovens were nearby in the open.

Most dwellings had a small dam at the front with ducks or hens. Some had on their tiny acreage a cow or a goat for milking. As far as possible these country folk appeared self-sufficient, even if it was only in a very rudimentary way. I do not romanticise this existence.

These recent experiences close to home have reminded me of that old religious concept of ‘penance’. It may not be such a bad thing after all. It can be challenging to do without or to jettison whatever has become an overindulgence for us – positional power, material possessions, status and image, food, grog, sarcasm or cynicism, dependence on social networking, or narcissism. In these recent days some of us have become increasingly aware of the penitential acts we owe to our natural environment – from taking it for granted.

And for more on Ash Wednesday, try tuning in late Wednesday evening to Fr Don Miller OFM, vocation director for the Franciscan Province of St. John the Baptist, who will explain Lent's "deeper call to conversion" in a live online chat here.

 


Michael MullinsStefan Gigacz is preparing a PhD. at MCD University of Divinity, Melbourne, on the role of Joseph Cardijn at Vatican II.

 

 

Disclaimer: CathBlog is an extension of CathNews story feedback. It is intended to promote discussion and debate among the subscribers to CathNews and the readers of the website. The opinions expressed in CathBlog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the members of the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference or of Church Resources.

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com


 


Recent Comments

  1. Thanks, Stefan, for the 'bits', even those I dislike.

  2. Poor Tracey! What a discovery that weighs so heavily on her.
    During 3 years with 2,500 Bishops praying for guidance, and with the assurance of Jesus all to the contrary, Tracey has concluded that the Holy Spirit took a lunch break when Gaudium et Spes was written.
    So much for the Scriptural truth that the 'Spirit blows where the Spirit wills'.
    Or perhaps Tracey is mistaken, even though she quotes the current Pope who was there at the Council as an advisor. '
    It seems strange to me that the Spirit took any kind of break from the Council, let alone just one, on such an important document.
    But then, we all want the Spirit on our side. Let the debate continue!

  3. It has become something of a fashion, even a trademark of neo-orthodoxy for its spokespeople to talk about the 'Gaudium et Spes generation' imbued with the Spirit of the Council and attendant caricatures of clown Masses and its mundane, pelagian, BBQ texts.
    It is also part of the scripted message uniformly broadcast that Vatican II and its documents have been misinterpreted, even distorted by subversives and that as a result, an official and definitive hermeneutic has been mandated.
    Recently, Maryknoll Fr William Grimm has offered his own corrective to the line put out by the promoters of the Reform of the Reform. Grimm, in a 03/10/12 UCAnews article, ppint out that the authentic hermeneutic for understanding Vatican II and its continuity with Tradition is not to be found in Porta Fidei or the Catechism of the Catholic Church or even in the combined magisterium of JPII and his successor but in the praxis of the 2,800 Bishops who made up the Concilium and issued its documents under their names and that of the Pope in communione.
    The meaning and intent of the Council should be found in what they actually did with the 'Spirit of the Council', how they interpreted the Council and their pastoral application of its messages. The Council was their making on behalf of the People of God. They did not 'misinterpret it.'
    Fr Grimm's article can be found at, http://www.ucanews.com/news/get-the-facts-straight/61597

  4. It takes a perverse and particularly distorted attachment to revisionist conservative theology to grudgingly conceed that Gaudium et Spes was OK!
    It is and was and will always be the seminal document of Vatican II, consistently betrayed ever since by lukewarm revanchists, appointed as a matter of deliberate ecclesiastical policy to positions of influence and power at all levels in the Church to turn the clock back!
    In this they will never succeed, despite their condemnations of faint praise, for who is there to deny the stunningly beautiful terms in which the Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World addresses that World:
    'The joys and the hopes, the griefs and the anxieties of the (people) of this age, especially those who are poor or in any way afflicted, these are the joys and hopes, the griefs and anxieties of the followers of Christ.' Let no one dare to deny this, for in doing so we deny Christ Himself!

  5. 'The joys and the hopes, the griefs and the anxieties of the (people) of this age, especially those who are poor or in any way afflicted, these are the joys and hopes, the griefs and anxieties of the followers of Christ.' Michael Furtado rightly assesses the importance of these words.
    Not a change, not a disconnection with Tradition, but a powerful statement firmly rooted in the doctrine of the Incarnation. (I still think the idea of the Incarnation is quite terrifying for those who can't trust the work of the Holy Spirit)!

  6. Dr Rowland's article is nuanced, so while I don't take issue with the defences of Gaudium et Spes presented in these comments, I don't think they engage with her critique at all.
    Quite frankly, I find it intellectually liberating to see intelligent discussion and criticism of Council documents.
    This was certainly not permitted when I was in the seminary — our theology professors seemed to think the Council documents 'came down from Heaven.'
    (In fairness to my lecturers, they showed more critical and thoughtful treatment to the documents of Vatican I or Trent. Not to mention the encyclicals of John Paul II.)

Bookmark and Share

More from this section

  1. Cathblog - To encourage the others – and ourselves

    We all know those weeks when we’ve had a bit of buffeting – work oversights, personal misunderstandings, family squabbles; the usual smooth sailing has become a briefly turbulent voyage and extra spiritual ballast is needed, writes Ann Rennie.

  2. Cathblog - The fear of fear

    These are difficult times: fiscal cliffs; gun control; sexual abuse; oppressive dictators; global warming; financial crises; the rise of secularism; potential nuclear threats; approaches to asylum seekers. And that is to name just a few. It appears that, at every turn in our lives, we are confronted by some form of fear, writes Garry Everett.

  3. Cathblog - Pentecost and the hero’s journey

    Can we hear the soft sibilance of the Holy Spirit urging us on, hinting at a change of heart, whispering to us as we pray that a new way might be found, suggesting somehow that there are other plans afoot and much work to be done, that our lives are moving in a new direction? This is what Pentecost is; a new start with the Spirit, writes Ann Rennie.

  4. Cathblog - You know what you like, but is it art?

    What defines art? This is a philosophical question that has focussed many an argument in recent decades. If great art can be defined as art that makes a difference to how you perceive something, or the truth about something, then the winner of the recent Mandorla Art Award, John Paul, has produced a great work of art, writes Angela McCarthy.

  5. Cathblog - Emergency learning

    The bushfire forecast for the next day was ‘catastrophic’ and this was our first summer in the bush. The sense of urgency waxed and waned as did the packing and the sorting. Needless to say, my wife and I were only partly prepared when the calamitous Tuesday arrived. But there had been discussion and this was a start. It also set me thinking, writes Richard White. What are my priorities? What would I most want to save and what losses would impact on me the most?

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Mass streamed live daily

From Our Lady of the Rosary Cathedral, Waitara, in the Broken Bay Diocese.
Weekdays live at 9.30am
Saturdays live 9.30am (followed by Adoration and Benediction)
Sundays live 9.30am
Click on this link at the appropriate time to connect.

Subscribe

To receive headlines from our faith-based news services, please subscribe below.

Email address

Newsletter


 

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.
Subscribe to Faith Project RSS.