Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

Catholics need a Pope for the New Evangelisation

Published: February 19, 2013

The challenges facing the successor of Pope Benedict XVI come into sharper focus when we widen the historical lens through which we view this papal transition. Benedict XVI will be the last pope to have participated in the Second Vatican Council, the most important Catholic event since the 16th century. An ecclesiastical era is ending. What was its character, and to what future has Benedict XVI led Catholicism? writes George Weigel in Ethics and Public Policy Centre.

Vatican II, which met from 1962 to 1965, accelerated a process of deep reform in the Catholic Church that began in 1878 when the newly elected Pope Leo XIII made the historic decision to quietly bury the rejectionist stand his predecessors had adopted toward cultural and political modernity and to explore the possibilities of a critical Catholic engagement with the contemporary world.

That reform process, which was not without difficulties, reached a high point of ecclesiastical drama at Vatican II, which has now been given an authoritative interpretation by two men of genius, John Paul II and Benedict XVI, both influential figures at the Council. According to that interpretation, the church must rediscover and embrace its vocation as a missionary enterprise.

Evangelical Catholicism -- or what John Paul II and Benedict XVI dubbed the "New Evangelization" -- is the new form of the Catholic Church being born today. The church is now being challenged to understand that it doesn't just have a mission, as if "mission" were one of a dozen things the church does. The churchisa mission.

At the centre of that mission is the proclamation of the Gospel and the offer of friendship with Jesus Christ. Everyone and everything in the church must be measured by mission-effectiveness. And at the forefront of that mission -- which now takes place in increasingly hostile cultural circumstances -- is the pope, who embodies the Catholic proposal to the world in a unique way.

So at this hinge moment, when the door is closing on the Counter-Reformation church in which every Catholic over 50 was raised, and as the door opens to the evangelical Catholicism of the future, what are the challenges facing the new pope?

Catholicism is dying in its historic heartland, Europe. The new pope must fan the frail flames of renewal that are present in European Catholicism. But he must also challenge Euro-Catholics to understand that only a robust, unapologetic proclamation of the Gospel can meet the challenge of a Christophobic public culture that increasingly regards biblical morality as irrational bigotry.

The new pope must be a vigorous defender of religious freedom throughout the world. Catholicism is under assault by the forces of jihadist Islam in a band of confrontation that runs across the globe from the west coast of Senegal to the eastern islands of Indonesia.

FULL STORY Catholics need a Pope for the New Evangelisation (EPPC)

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com


 


Recent Comments

  1. What we need is man who wants to a Saint!

  2. I. Weigel has a very strange view of history indeed. For reasons best known to himself he appears to believe that those who were actors in historical events are the best ones to interpret the historical significance of the event in his reference to John Paul II and Benedict XVI being present at Vatican II.
    If this was military history, would the account of two generals adequately account for what happened in a particular battle or its significance in the larger context of a war? Certainly, the accounts given by the generals would act as an authoritative source for the writing of history but to confuse authoritative source with authoritative interpretation is an undergraduate mistake not one that we would expect from someone with the profile of Wegiel.
    The fact is we are still trying to make sense of the Council of Trent.
    If only deep reform in Catholic Church did really begin in 1878. If this had have happened as a Church, we would not be out of breath as we try to catch up with all of the insights from the natural and human sciences that happened since 1878.
    Weigel claims that with the retirement of Benedict XVI an ecclesiastical era is ending?
    When the last ANZAC soldier died did an era end? I think not. I am not sure we are at a hinge moment either.
    Jihadist Islam across the globe from the west coast of Senegal to the eastern islands of Indonesia? Bali is Hindu.

  3. I don't consider Weigel's views strange at all, pace your first responder.
    He has spent a lot of time in Rome acquiring first-hand, intimate knowledge of key personages there. His remarks about Europe and the dangers of Islam are germane and, obviously, the compressed result of considerable thought and life experience.
    To many of us, the phrase 'hinge moment' rings true.

  4. John Francis Collins: Your analogy of 'generals' and their respective capacities might well apply in a secular military context, but it limps in failing to acknowledge that the two ecclesial 'generals' under discussion were eminently qualified as interpreters of Vatican II in virtue of their unique position and role as pope.
    Even those who assert a 'hermeneutic of discontinuity' between Vatican II and the Catholic Church's past recognise - demonstrably and, regrettably, with dismay - the interpretation delivered 'una voce' by John Paul II and Benedict XVI and accepted as authoritative by the vast majority of the world's Catholics.

  5. An interesting and thoughtful contribution, identifying some of the challenges facing a new Pope.
    In 'new evangelization' we need to ask what will be new?
    Are we to assume that the evangelium (good news) will be the same, but that the manner of announcing and living it will be different?
    George mentions the challenges of other religions, but he did no mention the need to befriend the stranger, shelter the homeless, visit the sick, in new ways that speak to our age.
    The Pope will need to consider these aspects of being church as well.
    George writes that 'there can be neither true freedom nor true democracy without full religious freedom.'
    It made me ask whether there can be true religious freedom without true democracy in the Church.
    We are constantly reminded that the Church is not a democracy, but maybe the new Pope needs to think about the association of religious freedom and democracy as part of his new evangelization.
    The notion reminds one of the dream that a certain Jesus had for a style of relationships, and of his early disciples who shared 'all things in common'.
    At least the new Pope won't need to be looking for work!

  6. Garry: One aspect of the new evangelisation is the novel challenge of awakening faithful responsiveness to Christ and living proclamation of his truth in now nominally Christian societies where the salt of the Gospel has lost its tang or has been all but buried under the weight of secular compromise.
    Richard Rymarz's recent book, The New Evangelisation can, I believe, shed some light on your question(Connor Court, 2012).

  7. There is still some confusion about with regard to understanding the meaning and significance of large historical events.
    The writings of Winston Churchill are regarded as a very authoritative source in attempting to understand the history and significance of WWII. He was there and Prime Minister of the UK.
    Let's be honest; we are still trying to make sense of WWII. Was the firebombing of Dresden just? Even an authoritative source such as Churchill cannot give us the last word on these issues.
    In terms of hinge, what has changed? What box is to be shut with a lid or what book is to be closed? I was serious in suggesting we are still trying to make sense of the Council of Trent. It is far too early to close the book on Vatican II simply because the participants at the event are no longer with us.
    Catholicism is a living tradition it did not die when the last apostle died. We are still trying to understand the significance of the life death and Resurrection of Jesus Christ. This is an ongoing and ever incomplete task.
    All of the Councils and all of the Popes are significant parts of that ongoing story. Apart from some rethinking with regard to the role of the pope in the life of the Church, I suggest it is difficult to see why the word 'hinge' is appropriate at this time.

  8. JFC: Metaphorically, a 'hinge moment' suggests change, but not radical disconnection, in the context of Church history.

  9. If metaphorically, a 'hinge moment' suggests change, but not radical disconnection, then Vatican II was a hinge event.
    Are we talking sizes of hinges?
    The 21st Ecumenical Council was a huge hinge event. There were changes the changes were significant but it was undertaken in the same manner as the 20 that had preceded it. Vatican II is part of the living tradition of the Church.
    Wiegel describes Vatican II as the most important Catholic event since the 16th century. He then goes on to say that because the participants who were there are no longer active in the Church that ‘an ecclesiastical era is ending’.
    I find it difficult to follow his line of thought. He seems to think that somehow that the 16 Documents that were promulgated by Paul VI that are the fruit of the Council have been finally and definitively interpreted by John Paul II and Benedict XVI.
    My own sense is that neither JP II nor BXVI would make such a claim.
    Both of these giants had (have) too much respect for the Church as Church and an awareness of how careful one needs to be in one's pronouncements as a Pope. JP II was a great philosopher and BXVI remains a great theologian. I am not sure that as a commentator Weigel is in the same ball park. My comments relate to Weigel's academic competency as I think his lack of competency undermines his authority.

Bookmark and Share

More from this section

  1. Featured website - Pro Bono Australia

    Pro Bono Australia is a useful one-stop shop for information about the community sector. It publishes news, the Australian Directory of Not for Profit Organisations, and has space for NFPs to advertise for staff or find events.

  2. Hansel and Gretel: Witchunters

    Don’t be fooled by the title. What appears to be simply a revamp of the classic Grimm’s fairy tale is one of the nastiest films made for some time, and it is harmful and dangerous on a number of levels.

  3. What Catholic school teaches

    I loved Catholic school because it was an epicentre for community. Every classmate knew their friends' families -- after all, there were only 20 of us, reminisces John McCarthy in NCR Online.

  4. Penpals with St Mary

    She was a pioneering woman of her time and remains the most influential religious figure in Australian history. Now the story of one of her most endearing friendships. The Southern Cross reports on the little-known details of the friendship between St Mary of the Cross MacKillop and Adelaide philanthropist and socialite Joanna Barr Smith.

  5. Website - Catholics in Coalition for Justice and Peace

    Catholics in Coalition for Justice and Peace is a coalition of individuals and groups, working for the emergence of just social structures in Australia and overseas. The website carries details of campaigns, letters and other activities.

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Mass streamed live daily

From Our Lady of the Rosary Cathedral, Waitara, in the Broken Bay Diocese.
Weekdays live at 9.30am
Saturdays live 9.30am (followed by Adoration and Benediction)
Sundays live 9.30am
Click on this link at the appropriate time to connect.

Subscribe

To receive headlines from our faith-based news services, please subscribe below.

Email address

Newsletter


 

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.
Subscribe to Faith Project RSS.