Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

The successes and failures of Benedict XVI

Published: February 14, 2013

Pope Benedict has led the Catholic Church since 2005, and his papacy has reflected his belief that the Catholic Church should retain its core traditional, conservative values in an era of rapid change.

He rejected calls for a debate on the issue of clerical celibacy, and reaffirmed the ban on Communion for divorced Catholics who remarry. He has also said the Church's strict positions on abortion, euthanasia and gay partnerships were "not negotiable".

This outspoken orthodoxy has divided liberals and more traditional Catholics, while the recent leaking of personal documents suggests a lack of control over the machinations of the Vatican.

How has Benedict XVI managed the world's largest Christian community? We asked six scholars and analysts for their perspective on key areas of the pontificate.


Governance - Clifford Longley

Pope Benedict was clearly shocked and disappointed that one of those closest to him, his butler Paolo Gabriele, had been a source of the leaked Vatican documents that revealed a state of turmoil inside the central government of the Catholic Church.

The Curia - the central government of the Church - appeared to be riddled with rival factions and there were accusations of corruption in high places.

Observers had long labelled the Vatican a dysfunctional institution - now the details were laid bare.
Many curial officials, men dedicated to the good of the Church, felt frustrated and exasperated by the institutional sclerosis they encountered.

Pope Benedict may well have realised that in his 86th year he no longer had the energy to do what needed to be done to sort this all out.

That, and his inability to go on travelling the great distances that the job demands, may well have been what persuaded him to abdicate - for the good of the Church.

The reform of the Vatican, which he had only begun at the margins, has a long way to go yet.
Decentralisation is now imperative. His successor has a huge and unenviable task.


Evangelisation - Austen Ivereigh

In speeches, addresses and teaching documents Benedict XVI considered how to present the Gospel to cultures steeped in Christian values yet often hostile to the Church.

This specific challenge, known as the "new evangelisation" ("new" referring to the context rather than the message), was one of Pope Benedict's priorities: he created a new Vatican department to promote it, and last October called together the world's bishops to agree how to take it forward.

FULL STORY Viewpoints: successes and failures of Benedict XVI (BBC)

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com


 


Recent Comments

  1. Amazing, isn't it?
    Suddenly everyone is an expert on how a Pope ought to behave in the 21st century.
    The closest I ever came to the Pope was that I walked through the cavernous Sistine chapel two years ago.
    Everything else I know about him is either through his writings/speeches or the mass media coverage of his activities.
    The BBC has done a fair job in obtaining the views of six specialists/analysts on the performance of Benedict XVI - a bit like getting six experienced diving judges to assess the performance of a highboard Olympic competitor. Some of these judges might have been champion divers in their day and there's the rub - no one has ever been Pope.
    No one knows the job from the inside.
    As far as I can judge, no Pope in recent times specifically trained for the job, particularly wanted the job, and if anyone of them particularly sought to win a Gold Medal for their performance, not one of them showed it.
    If I were a judge I would score Benedict 6/6 for his take off, the encyclical God is Love and 6/6 for his entry into the water of retirement, his resignation.
    Between the beginning and the end falls the shadow - the shadow of the bureaucracy that was meant to advise him for the good of the universal church.
    That's where his performance seemed to lose its shape - but I am in no position to judge.
    Amen

    .

  2. Perhaps leave the Papacy vacant for a year while all people prayed and considered the real requirements of the job at this point in history.
    The current caretaker Cardinal could keep the Vatican ticking over while penance and reflection took place by the Clergy during Lent, Easter and Pentecost and allowed for and gathered input from the Laity by consultations with local parish groups to flesh out current needs of the Church.
    It would also allow the various Government enquiries into the sexual abuse issues to be addressed and some progress to be made on resolving the crises.
    Then there may be a better process of selection of a Pope who has the backing of the whole Church wih a fixed term of occupancy.

Bookmark and Share

More from this section

  1. Featured website - Heroic news.org

    Heroic Media, a faith-based company that promotes alternatives to abortion through mass media, has an online news portal at Heroicnews.org. The initiative is aimed at making a broad cultural impact, complementing its current outreach to women in crisis pregnancies.

  2. Flight

    Denzel Washington has received an Oscar nomination for his portrayal in the movie Flight of a middle-aged, regional airline captain who expertly lands a plane load of passengers, averting a near catastrophe. But his hero status quickly unravels as his drug and alcohol abuse are revealed.

  3. A society that leaves no room for ageing

    The Pope’s gesture was almost an act of surrender before the world which is changing at a rhythm which a man born in 1927 could never have imagined. It is not just the means and timings of communication that are changing. Today’s world requires that every single detail be communicated and at once, writes Mario Calabresi, editor of La Stampa, inVatican Insider.

  4. In hindsight, Pope's resignation seems almost predictable

    As much as he astonished the world when he announced his resignation, Pope Benedict XVI's decision seems almost predictable in hindsight. Given his previous statements on the subject and his recent signs of aging, one might say that people should have seen it coming, reports the Catholic News Service. 

  5. Featured websites - Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle + Catholic Schools

    The Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle has completed a new website, in coordination with new branding and logos. In addition, the local Catholic Schools Office site was also relaunched, featuring professional portrait photography from every school.

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Mass streamed live daily

From Our Lady of the Rosary Cathedral, Waitara, in the Broken Bay Diocese.
Weekdays live at 9.30am
Saturdays live 9.30am (followed by Adoration and Benediction)
Sundays live 9.30am
Click on this link at the appropriate time to connect.

Subscribe

To receive headlines from our faith-based news services, please subscribe below.

Email address

Newsletter


 

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.
Subscribe to Faith Project RSS.