Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

New dispute between WYD and Sydney City Council

Published: June 16, 2008

A new dispute has broken out between Sydney City Council and Word Youth Day organisers over who will pay for repairs to the city's famous Hyde Park.

The Sydney Morning Herald reports Lord Mayor Clover Moore plans to kick Pope Benedict and the six day World Youth Day festival out of the council controlled Hyde Park for failing to pay their bills on time.

The extraordinary stand off between the City of Sydney supremo and the pontiff follows the Catholic Church's failure to pay a $150,000 bond for use of the park by a 5pm deadline on Friday.

WYD organisers had planned to start setting up the key pilgrims' site with a giant video screen, confessional booths, merchandise stands and marquees across the road from St Mary's Cathedral.

At least half of Hyde Park is expected to be closed for up to three months after World Youth Day to repair damage from thousands of Catholic pilgrims treading on the turf.

It is understood Church authorities had told the council that the Iemma Government was paying.

Potential problems emerged in the past fortnight when the council asked them to sign an event permit for the use of the park and pay the required bond. Unless the money is paid, the Church cannot use the park for their event.

"The City supports the event, but not at the expense of our most famous park," the Lord Mayor said. "WYD organisers have applied to install structures in many parts of Hyde Park, some of which will be in place from June 20 to August 1. There is no question that many of the grassed areas of Hyde Park will need to be re-turfed after this event but now, just weeks before it's due to start, organisers are backing down on a commitment to fully fund the cost of restoring Hyde Park to its pre-WYD condition.

"As trustees of the Crown land space, the City has a responsibility and obligation to ensure Hyde Park is looked after. We are determined to ensure Sydney is not left with a significantly damaged park and ratepayers aren't lumped with a hefty bill.

"All we are requesting is for the Church or the Government to pay a bond and honour their earlier promise to restore areas of Hyde Park damaged by WYD events. Similar conditions are expected from all other hirers of Hyde Park."

WYD spokesman Jim Hanna said Church representatives were in discussions "to resolve this issue".

"The City of Sydney has been a strong supporter of world youth day," Mr Hanna said. "They are still a strong supporter, and Hyde Park is central to the support they're giving us. We are confident this issue will be resolved soon.

A spokesman for Deputy Premier John Watkins said "the City and state have both been strong supporters of this event, and we are confident a resolution will be found".

Cr Moore said organisers from WYD and the Government's coordination authority raised no objections at a council meeting on May 5, when the sponsorship report was discussed, clearly stating the cost of repairing Hyde Park would be covered by either the church or the Government.

The council also claims that it has in writing from church officials an agreement to their requirements to pay for the rehabilitation.

A report to the City of Sydney's finance committee estimated WYD will cost the council about $2.2 million, a figure that covers extra expenses such as cleaning and staffing, as well as forgone revenue.

Cr Moore said the cost and the inconvenience would be worth it, but she was standing firm on the agreed bond for the rehabilitation of the park.

Meanwhile, the final race meeting at Randwick until at least September was held yesterday. The racetrack will be officially handed over to World Youth Day organisers today, with Australian Jockey Club chief Norman Gillespie praying it will be returned in good condition.

"This is a huge logistical operation of unprecedented scale and complexity," Mr Gillespie said.

"You could say it took an act of God to stop training at Royal Randwick," Mr Gillespie said. "Every single livestock truck in the land has been summoned for the grand evacuation. It's like Dunkirk."

Another report says that horses that horses will be ejected from Centennial Park but dogs and their walkers will be able to roam the parkland during the weekend visit of Pope Benedict XVI to Randwick.

The 268 hectares of parkland, well used by Sydneysiders, will be an overflow venue for pilgrims gathered not only for the papal closing Mass on July 20 but, in a late development, now for the evening vigil the night before.

SOURCE

Church must cover Hyde Park costs: Sydney council

It's Clover versus God in park fight

Pilgrims rein in horses' parade

LINKS

World Youth Day 2008

MORE STORIES

Act of God punts racehorses out of Randwick 

Ceremonial farewell for Pier Giorgio

Critical mass

 

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com


 


Recent Comments

  1. WYD is going to be a spectacular event, and 'prime time' for witness to Christ. However, what about the thousands of people whose lives will be disrupted by this event? I would have hoped that Cardinal Pell in his wisdom would make an apology to the people of Sydney for any disruption to their lives caused by the preparations and cleaning up and replanting before and after WYD. What is the Cardinal's Media Person doing, for heaven's sake? Say something to the people of Sydney sooner rather than later. Your silence can appear to be arrogance towards the people of Sydney. It seems that the WYD Juggernaught is just going to move through and interfere, knock down and trample anything in its way! Come on Cardinal Pell, Sydney is waiting to hear from you, and do have a smile for us and project some kind of joy instead of looking so tired, cranky and worn out!

  2. This sounds to me like yet another media beatup!
    Still I agree with Kevin that the media people for WYD should appologise for any inconvenience caused, as there is no doubt it will cause hassles to people if the Cologne experience is any guide.

  3. As WYD comes closer, there appears to be an increase in stories pointing to the astonishingly inept organisation of the event. It is disturbing enough to read about the dispute between Sydney City Council and the church over payment for the rehabilitation of Hyde Park but even more disturbing and unjust, is the apparent reluctance of the organisers to pay freelance artists for their work.
    Artists and crafts people on the whole, depend on ongoing payment and/or prompt payment on completion of work, to merely survive. This from the Catholic Church that preaches justice!!

    The frantic calls in parishes for volunteers to feed, accommodate and/or supervise the pilgrims appears to be another example of inadequate organisation.

    This Catholic is embarrassed by the perceived arrogant expectation that private citizens, government, local government and non-government organisations will pick up the tab and the mess and, put up and shut up.

  4. THREE MONTHS to roll out grass onto Hyde Park and water it? I know someone who could do the job in 24 hours.

  5. I walked through Hyde Park the day after WYD ended, and the grass is in BETTER condition than it usually is, with virtually no sign of trampling. M's Moore and her council are a disgrace.

Bookmark and Share

More from this section

  1. Pope to Ballina?

    The northern New South Wales town of Ballina is buzzing with rumours that Pope Benedict may spend his three day break there prior to World Youth Day.

  2. Churches not learning on abuse: Briggs

    University of South Australia lecturer, Professor Freda Briggs, will today tell a psychiatrists convention that churches have failed to learn the lesson of massive abuse compensation payouts.

  3. Quick fix for charity workers

    The federal government will introduce last minute legislation next week to prevent low paid Church and charity workers from losing family tax entitlements.

  4. Vatican official challenges Israel over archives

    The president of the Pontifical Committee for Historical Sciences says that Israel has 15 sets of archives relating to Pope Pius XII and the Holocaust which are not open to historical researchers.

  5. Benedict to confirm 14 Aussies

    Pope Benedict will confirm 14 young Australians during this year's World Youth Day events.

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Mass streamed live daily

From Our Lady of the Rosary Cathedral, Waitara, in the Broken Bay Diocese.
Weekdays live at 9.30am
Saturdays live 9.30am (followed by Adoration and Benediction)
Sundays live 9.30am
Click on this link at the appropriate time to connect.

Subscribe

To receive headlines from our faith-based news services, please subscribe below.

Email address

Newsletter


 

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.
Subscribe to Faith Project RSS.