High Court challenge to postal survey begins

Postal surveys are due to be sent to households next week (Australia Post)

The High Court has begun hearing a challenge to the federal government's planned voluntary postal survey on same-sex marriage, with two groups opposed to the policy arguing it has not been properly funded, ABC News reports.

Just a week before the first survey forms are sent to households, the full bench of the High Court is hearing challenges against the survey from two separate groups.

It was standing room only in the Melbourne courtroom – modified to accommodate the court, whose usual home in Canberra is under renovation.

The main focus of the challenge is that Finance Minister Mathias Cormann sought to use a funding pool set aside for urgent or unforeseen matters, which could be used without parliamentary approval to pay for the $122 million survey.

The survey was announced by the government last month, after the Senate twice rejected a compulsory plebiscite on same-sex marriage.

One of the groups opposing the survey is headed up by independent MP Andrew Wilkie, the other is comprised of Australian Marriage Equality and Greens senator Janet Rice.

Ron Merkel, who is representing the group led by Mr Wilkie, told the court yesterday there was nothing urgent or unforeseen about the plans.

But he said his main argument against the survey was that the executive government had been given power to determine how the funding was allocated.

He said the Constitution required acts to include provisions that revenue be appropriated by a vote of Parliament.

"The Parliament has impermissibly conferred power on the Minister," he said.

Mr Merkel said that power had allowed the Minister to change the items, add items and alter the amounts to be spent in a way which the legislator has not provided for.

The government maintains the appropriation of money was appropriate, as the survey met the definition of unforeseen and urgent.

The court also heard arguments from Mr Wilkie's lawyers that the government was asking the Australian Bureau of Statistics to collect opinions, when it is bound by legislation to only collect statistics.

The case is expected to continue today, when the court will hear submissions from the Commonwealth, defending the plans for the survey.

FULL STORY

Same-sex marriage survey funding 'not urgent, not unforeseen', High Court hears (ABC News)

RELATED COVERAGE

Marriage survey forms printing under way (News.com.au)

Without proper protections, same-sex marriage will discriminate against conscientious objectors (MercatorNet)

Almost half of SA federal politicians to ignore results of public vote on same-sex marriage (Adelaide Now)

'Not the best of Australia': Both sides of same-sex marriage debate worry Alan Joyce (ABC News)

Mass on Demand

home-video-thumbnail

From Parish of Our Lady of The Way, North Sydney & Lavender Bay. The first Mass of the day on YouTube

Mass Online

home-video-thumbnail-nobttn

Live streamed from Our Lady of the Rosary Cathedral, Waitara

more

Daily Prayer

Daily Prayer

All your daily readings, reflections and prayers can be found here... 

view